Prashant Kishor & Pavan Varma Went from Nitish Kumar’s ‘War Room’
NEW DELHI/ PATNA: Nitish Kumar, the Chief Minister of Bihar, today expelled two of his closest aides, Prashant Kishor and Pavan Varma, after weeks of acrimony over their open criticism of his stand on the citizenship law. In their parting shot on Twitter, both said “thank you” and wished their ex-boss luck in retaining the “chief minister’s chair”.
The move was imminent. Nitish Kumar had declared over the past few days that the two were “free to leave”.Prashant Kishor, the ace election strategist credited with Nitish Kumar’s 2015 Bihar victory, exits on the verge of another election.
A day after Mr. Kumar said, “It’s okay if he [Kishor] stays or goes from the party”, JD(U) principal general secretary K C Tyagi on Wednesday issued a press release, which said that both Mr. Kishor and Mr. Varma have been expelled from the primary membership of the party for working and issuing statements against it and its chief.
“Thank you Nitish Kumar. My best wishes to you to retain the chair of Chief Minister of Bihar. God bless you,” Mr Kishor tweeted.
Pavan Varma, who had rattled Nitish Kumar with an open letter referring to conversations criticizing the BJP, added: “Thank you Nitish Kumar ji for freeing me from my increasingly untenable position of defending you and your policies. I wish you well in your ambition of being CM of Bihar at any cost.”
As vice president of Janata Dal United (JDU) since 2018, Mr Kishor had been virtual number two to Nitish Kumar. That relationship rapidly soured after Mr Kishor publicly called out his party boss in tweets and urged him to take a firm stand on the Citizenship (Amendment) Act CAA and the National Register for Citizens (NRC).
Mr Kishor questioned the party’s support to the CAA in parliament just days after Nitish Kumar expressed his reservations at a party meeting. In December, he was persuaded by the JDU chief to drop the idea of quitting, but the social media attacks resumed.
Nitish Kumar betrayed his fury at Mr Kishor yesterday when he repeated a controversial comment on inducting Mr Kishor at BJP leader Amit Shah’s instance. “Someone wrote a letter I replied to it. Someone is tweeting, let him a tweet. What do I’ve to do with it? One can stay at the party till he wants. He can go if he wants…Do you know how did he join the party? Amit Shah asked me to induct him,” he said.
former diplomat Pavan Varma had successfully run the ‘war room’ of Nitish Kumar during the 2015 Bihar assembly elections and installed him as chief minister of the Grand Alliance comprising Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) and Janata Dal (United).
Five years after, they are waging a ‘war’ against Kumar, berating him over his support to the CAA and seeking his categorical stand on the National Population Register (NPR) and the National Register for Citizens (NRC), besides the JD(U)’s poll alliance with the BJP for the ensuing Delhi Assembly elections.
Varma has sought ‘ideological clarity’ from Kumar over CAA, NPR and NRC in view of the ongoing agitation against them, while Kishor has been venting his displeasure over the party’s stand on the contentious law.
On Tuesday, the party president and his deputy were entangled in another war of words, with Kishor accusing Kumar of lying about the circumstances in which he joined the party. While Kumar said Kishor was inducted into the JN(U) at BJP leader Amit Shah’s direction, Kishor dismissed the allegation as “a lie”.
Meanwhile, the matter raised by Varma also pertains to the personal views of Kumar about the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), describing the saffron outfit as the “most dangerous” for the country. Varma claimed that Kumar, in private conversations, had derided the “divisive” agenda of the BJP and wanted the democratic and socialist forces to regroup against the saffron brigade.
What had embarrassed Kumar the most amid the raging controversy within the JD(U) was the caustic criticism made by the leader of opposition in the Bihar Assembly, Tejashwi Prasad Yadav, over the chief minister’s viewpoint on the RSS.
“When I used to sit next to him in the Assembly, he used to tell me that the RSS people are dangerous,” Yadav said during a debate in the state Assembly convened recently for a day to ratify the SC and ST Bill passed by Parliament.
Their outbursts for the past month have evoked sharp reactions from Kumar, who said Varma was free to go anywhere he wanted. “He should have raised issues, if any, on party platform instead of releasing it publicly. Would I ever go public with what he has said to me in private?” Kumar asked.
On Tuesday, Kumar reiterated the same stand in connection with Kishor, saying people are free to remain in the party or leave if they want. The JD(U) chief’s response came when he was asked about a series of tweets by Kishor taking a strident position on the NRC and the CAA.
It is certainly a warning to Kishor to look for another political platform. Party insiders claimed that Varma and Kishor might be expelled from the party soon for indulging in “anti-party activities” and “weakening” it before the Delhi polls.
It is an irony that Kumar has been facing scathing attacks from Kishor and Varma, whom he had banked upon the most, ignoring even trusted lieutenants like Rajiv Ranjan Singh alias Lallan Singh and RCP Singh.
Both Varma and Kishor were inducted into the JD(U) with great fanfare in a bid to give the party an image makeover and project the hitherto regional party as a national one.
Varma, a career diplomat and writer, had taken premature retirement from the Indian Foreign Service (IFS) to join Kumar in 2013. He has since served as culture adviser to the Bihar chief minister. Varma was also given a two-year stint in the Rajya Sabha and later made the party’s general secretary and national spokesperson.
In 2015, Varma was instrumental in roping in poll strategist Kishor for the JD(U)’s campaign in the crucial Assembly elections when Kumar had broken the alliance with the BJP and joined hands with the Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD).
As an election strategist, Kishor played an important role in bringing the JD(U) and RJD under the banner of ‘Mahagathbandhan’ (Grand Alliance) during the 2015 Assembly polls and pitched for Kumar’s victory in the polls.
In a major makeover in his campaign strategy to connect with people, a hi-tech ‘war room’ was set up on the advice of Kishor at the 7, Circular Road, official bungalow where Kumar lived after quitting as chief minister, owning moral responsibility for the party’s defeat in the 2014 Lok Sabha elections.
Besides Kishor, the then Rajya Sabha MP Varma was also among those in charge of the ‘war room’, with five party spokespersons in attendance. Kishor, who worked with the party top brass, had spread its message through different campaigns like Har Ghar Dastak, Bihari NDA, and seven-point Nitish Nischay to reach out to voters.
When Kumar left the Grand Alliance and returned to the NDA in 2017, Kishor was inducted into the JD(U) in September 2018 and made the party’s national vice-president with the task of negotiating seat-sharing with the BJP before the crucial 2019 Lok Sabha polls. Kishor’s elevation in the party’s ranks had raised eyebrows but sulking party leaders grudgingly accepted it.
Initially, Kumar seems to have used Kishor and Varma to rein in the BJP over the CAA although officially, the JD(U) supported the bill in both Houses of Parliament. However, the situation changed after the Jharkhand polls in which the NDA constituents lost to the JMM-Congress-RJD alliance ostensibly because they fought the polls separately.
Consequently, the JD(U) changed its stand on the NPR and CAA and decided to fight the Delhi Assembly polls in alliance with the BJP. While the BJP is contesting from 67 of the 70 seats, the JD(U) is contesting from two. The Lok Janshakti Party (LJP) — the third NDA partner — is contesting from one.
The Jharkhand debacle seems to have forced the JD(U) and other NDA allies to change their strategy and fight the polls together to avoid wastage of votes. At the national executive meeting held in June last year, the JD(U) had announced it will not be a part of the BJP-led NDA outside Bihar and contest Assembly polls in states on its own.
The decision was taken in a bid to expand the its presence and to attain the status of a nationally-recognised party by 2020. As part of this strategy, the JD(U) fought the Assembly elections in Jharkhand separately but could not open its account.
It was due to the objections raised by Varma and Kishor to ally with the BJP in Delhi that they have been excluded from the list of JD(U)’s star campaigners in the upcoming Delhi polls. They had stressed that BJP ally Akali Dal has taken a stand on contentious issues like the CAA and the NRC and decided not to go with the BJP in the ensuing Delhi polls.
(Agency Inputs with Prerna Pratap Report).
